Wednesday, June 08, 2005

Trial of the Century

(Update below)
(cross-posted at The Shotgun)

Tomorrow, at 9:45 a.m. Eastern Standard Time, the Supreme Court of Canada will rule in the case of Chaoulli and Zeliotis v. Government of Quebec. Amongst possible rulings is that the prohibition on private care in Canada contravenes section 7 Charter guarantees to life, liberty, and security of the person.

That is, if Canadians have to wait so long for care--which they do--then their security of the person is violated. They should be free to pursue a private option within Canada should the government prove to be incapable of providing timely care in gov-run hospitals.

In anticipation of the ruling, I'm posting my conversation with Jacques Chaoulli for the Western Standard cover story entitled "Freedom Fighter." You can listen to it by clicking here (it's a WAV file). I do sound like a bit of an idiot in there at parts, but I guess that's forgivable...

The newsmedia is somewhat silent on this issue the day before the ruling. My Google News Alert provides me with three links:
Medicare Future at Stake (National Post)
Medicare's Future on the line (Alaska Highway News)
The Montreal Economic Institute made its presence to the media known in a press release.

Silence before the storm?

What? A Supreme Court case? Quick, where's my keyboard? Ahh... here it is:
Top Court to rule on Medicare Test Case (Globe & Mail) (5:19 p.m. Ahem.)
Labour unions issue a press release as well, noting their intention to be available for comment.

****Back to original post****

And here, for your background reading, are a few links to keep you busy:

WS: Freedom Fighter (Web) (PDF) (2004/10/11)
NY Times: A challenger to Canada's Health Care (2005/05/22)
CBC: Top court to hear private health-care challenge. (2003/05/08)
SC Press release: Case heard before Supreme Court (2004/06/08)
Margaret Wente: The dangerous ideas of Dr. Jacques Chaoulli. (2004/06/08)


Blogger Jonathan said...

I agree. I think this is going to be huge. I predict a major result. Government loses.

4:29 p.m.  
Blogger P. M. Jaworski said...

You were right, Jonathan. You were right.

9:54 p.m.  

Post a Comment

<< Home