Wednesday, December 13, 2006

Liberaltarians

About a week ago I mentioned Lind's article about the death of libertarianism. Since then, I have come across many articles that claim just the opposite. That libertarianism is not dead, but is finding a new home... on the left.

I'll explain in a second. I should also point out that Lind's article may have misdiagnosed the problem. It is not that libertarianism is dead, but that the conservatism of Republicans, as it used to be, is dead.

Why are the tales of libertarianism's death exaggerated? One reason to think this is because libertarians have shifted gears. Instead of aiming their arguments at economic liberty, they have begun to target social conservatism, and begun taking social libertarianism more seriously. If this is so, many writers, like Lind, may be confusing libertarians for liberals. When someone writes in defence of ending the war on drugs, they may be libertarians, but Lind may falsely believe that it is a liberal writing. So he's not counting enough libertarians.

Libertarianism is a political philosophy that can be described as both left and right, as both liberal and conservative, in different respects. It is left and liberal on social issues (drugs, sex, and rock and roll); it is right and conservative on economic issues (anti-tax, and pro-free market ). It is for small government and liberty through-and-through. Conservatives are in favour of small government with respect to economics ("mind your own business"--where "business" means economic enterprise), but in favour of big government when it comes to social issues and the military. Social democrats (as they are called in Europe) and liberals (as they are, alas, alas, called in Anglo-America--but not in Australia! In Australia, "liberals" are still pro-liberty on both social and economic issues. Would that the rest of us were as wise about words as Australians... but I digress...) are in favour of small government with respect to social issues ("mind your own business"--where "business" means affairs), but in favour of big government when it comes to economic issues.

Libertarians are in favour of people minding their own business in both of the above senses of "business." Mind your own affairs, and mind your own economic enterprises. Just in case this is interpreted as thorough-going interpersonal isolationism, the libertarian claim is that what shouldn't mind my or your business is the government. You and I can take an interest in one another's businesses. We can try to persuade others that they should do one thing, rather than another. The claim is importantly restricted to the activities of governments, and not of churches, persons, charities, other institutions and so on. Libertarians can be busybodies. They can run around telling other people how they should run their lives, and how they should run their businesses. Libertarians just take very seriously the prohibition on doing so by making use of the government.

Sometimes they believe this because they believe that people shouldn't be coerced or forced to do things against their will. Some libertarians believe in what they call the "axiom of non-aggression," or something like a total prohibition on initiating force (Murray Rothbard comes to mind). I do not agree with these libertarians. In principle, I see nothing particularly wrong with forcing people to do what is right. By "in principle" I mean something like this. Suppose we had an oracle that could tell us everything, and knew everything. If we had such an oracle, there would be nothing wrong with coercing people to do what the oracle says. The problem is that we don't have this oracle. So we may be opposed to paternalism, coercion, and the use of force for practical reasons. We may believe that, for instance, giving someone the power to coerce us when we all agree that it is the right thing to do will not keep them from coercing us when we think it is the wrong thing to do. We may believe that, in practice, while some institution manages to get it right a lot of the times, they can get it wrong, sometimes horribly, terribly wrong. We may believe that the benefit of allowing coercion in cases where they will get it right is outweighed by the cost of those times when they get it wrong. This is what I believe. But this is another digression.

Conservatives found appeal in libertarianism when libertarianism expressed its economic arguments. Milton Friedman, Friedrich Hayek, James Buchanan, and so on, were all popular figures in the '60s, '70s, and '80s. Most everybody knew their names, and was familiar with a handful of their arguments. Libertarians, at the time, probably sharpened their pens and got busy writing about economics because the biggest threat was to economic liberty. Communism comes to mind, as does socialism. These were real threats to liberty, real reasons to focus on economics. Communism is no longer a "real" threat, "real" in the sense of being politically feasible. Socialism is also no longer a "real" threat. (This is my perception, I'm guessing many others share this perception). Since this is so, many may have turned, or are now beginning to turn, to social liberty issues. Drugs, gays, and a culture of liberty.

This makes it natural for libertarians to begin abandoning conservatism, especially since modern-day conservatism in the Republican Party means supporting somewhat different big government programs from the Democratic Party's big government programs. This abandonment appears to be happening. The most significant of these articles is Brink Lidsay's article entitled "Liberaltarians" in the New Republic. I could not get past the first paragraph (firewall), but then found the article on Cato's website, where Lindsay works. In this article, Lindsay is pleading with libertarians to dump the elephants in favour of the donkeys. He is also arguing that liberals and libertarians in America have more in common, when you consider everything, than libertarians and conservatives do. Good for him. I agree. Read the article.

Today, meanwhile, the Economist chimes in with an article that argues the Republicans should target their guns at the Libertarian Party. This is a short article, but it expresses what I take to be a fact. In many cases, many libertarians are shifting their vote to Democrats, and the Libertarian Party, as a way of venting their anger with Republicans. Good for them. I support this move. Read the article.

Is libertarianism dead? Hardly. It's just shifting gears.

28 Comments:

Blogger William E. Demers said...

Libertarianism is still going strong on the right. Socialist libertarianism doesn't even work if you look at the numbers.

3:10 PM  
Blogger P. M. Jaworski said...

Do you mean "social" libertarianism? Socialist libertarianism is an oxymoron, I would have thought.

3:23 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I find just the opposite. Modern, progressive liberals have dropped the ball with respect to classic liberalism, and conservatives have picked it up and are beginning to run with it.

Libertarians would appear to be natural enemies of social conservatives, yet somehow they get along pretty well. One reason, perhaps, is that libertarians believe devoutly in freedom of conscience, which means they may be better equiped to tolerate a diversity of opinion. Progressive liberals, on the other hand, seem to be getting less and less tolerant. The speech codes found in universities are a prime example.

3:27 PM  
Anonymous Werner Patels said...

When read something like this ("Smoking ban in condos next step"), it's not hard to believe that libertarianism is dead, or will be dead soon.

9:46 PM  
Anonymous ericdondero said...

More libertarians were elected in the 2006 elections running under the GOP banner than practically any time before. The Republican Liberty Caucus backed over 120 candidates and 80% of them won. It was a glorious year for the RLC.

Not too mention many libertarian-leaning Republican Governors were elected, like Butch Otter in Idaho, Sarah Palin in Alaska, Mark Sanford in SC, and even Charlie Crist in Florida.

How anyone could interpret that as a sign that libertarians are abandoning the GOP for the Democrats is beyond me.

If anything the exact opposite is true. More and more Libertarian Party refugees are joining the RLC these days. In fact the LP's top elected official switched to the GOP back in August.

For a list of elected Libertarian Republicans go to www.mainstreamlibertarian.com

Eric Dondero
Houston, Texas

9:49 PM  
Blogger P. M. Jaworski said...

eric - Thanks for the link. It's interesting. But I guess I should have been clearer. When I say libertarians are abandoning the GOP, I don't mean that politicians who are libertarian are abandoning the GOP, but that libertarian, and libertarian-leaning *voters* are.

I'm glad to see it was a banner year for the RLC. I'm a fan of that group, and I'm glad their doing well.

Part of my post may be wishful thinking. I really do wish libertarians would punish the GOP, at least at the national level, for having so thoroughly abandoned liberty.

1:33 AM  
Blogger P. M. Jaworski said...

rabbit - I agree that University speech codes are bullshit. These kinds of liberals make my stomach turn.

My post was a 'balance of reasons' post, not a claim that liberals are pro-liberty, but that, maybe, just maybe, they are pro-liberty more so than conservatives.

Or, put differently, on the issues where casting a ballot for a liberal or conservative candidate has some chance of making a difference at the policy level, it may be better to vote liberal. I don't care if a politician believes that we should not be allowed to wake up any later than 10 in the morning, and promises to put forward a bill to that effect. A bill like that would be futile. I do care about their views on marijuana, however, for the simple reason that I believe it is not futile (or at least not *as* futile).

1:38 AM  
Blogger Omar Cruz said...

This page is fantastic, the infomation you show us is really interesting and is good written. Do you want to see something more? you can visit too: The marijuana care is an original annual plant of Asia,of diverse mountain ranges of the Himalaya.
Head Shop, Herbal Grinders
Bongs, Glass Pipe. Visit us for more info at: http://www.headshopinternational.com/

8:46 PM  
Blogger P. M. Jaworski said...

fghtr

6:58 AM  
Blogger Diana said...

Anarchism is a philosophy which embodies many diverse and heterogeneous attitudes, tendencies and schools of thought; as such, disagreement over questions of values, ideology and tactics is common. The compatibility of capitalism, nationalism and religion with anarchism is widely disputed. Similarly, anarchism enjoys a complex relationship with ideologies such as Marxism, communism and anarcho-capitalism. Anarchists may be motivated by humanism, divine authority, enlightened self-interest or any number of alternative ethical doctrines. Phenomena such as civilization, technology (e.g. within primitivism and insurrectionary anarchism), and the democratic process may be sharply criticized within some anarchist tendencies and simultaneously lauded in others. sportsbook, Anarchist attitudes towards race, gender and the environment have changed significantly since the modern origin of the philosophy in the eighteenth century. On a tactical level, while propaganda of the deed was a tactic used by anarchists in the 19th century (e.g. the Nihilist movement), contemporary anarchists espouse alternative methods such as nonviolence, counter-economics and anti-state cryptography to bring about an anarchist society. The diversity in anarchism has lead to widely different use of identical terms among different anarchist traditions, which has lead to many definitional concerns in anarchist theory. http://www.enterbet.com

3:02 PM  
Blogger kimberly sayer said...

Libertarianism is a political theory that advocates the maximization of individual liberty in thought and action and the minimization or even abolition of the state.costa rica fishingLibertarians embrace viewpoints across a political spectrum, ranging from pro-property to anti-property (phrased as "right" versus "left")and from minimal state (or minarchist) to openly anarchist.
http://www.fishingcostaricaexperts.com

11:00 AM  
Blogger JAYYYYYYYYYY said...

Libertarians have been described as "left" or "right" depending on their views of property rights. Right libertarians take a favorable view of private property.Costa rica toursFor example, according to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy right libertarians hold that natural resources "may be appropriated by the first person who discovers them, mixes labor with them.
http://www.kingtours.com

4:06 PM  
Blogger kiara said...

costa rica tours, shopping online, costa rica fishing, jaco fishing charters, costa rica whale watching, costa rica dolphin watching, costa rica party boat, panama fishing, fishing costa rica los suenos, los suenos fishing charters, costa rica fishing los suenos, los suenos costa rica fishing, costa rica los suenos fishing, fishing costa rica los suenos, los suenos fishing charters, costa rica fishing los suenos, los suenos costa rica fishing charters, costa rica los suenos fishing,
http://www.kingtours.com/.

3:17 PM  
Blogger anamika said...

I strongly comprehend that the help and advice provided is associated to just about every person . Thanks .
locksmith in hialeah
Locksmith in MARGATE FL
Oakland locksmith
Sunnyvale locksmith
Locksmith Sunnyvale CA
Sunnyvale locksmith
Locksmith Sunnyvale CA
Locksmith Sunnyvale
Naperville Locksmith
Naperville Locksmith
Locksmith Naperville
Locksmith Naperville
Locksmith Naperville IL
Locksmith Naperville
Locksmith Naperville
Locksmith Naperville IL
Locksmith Naperville IL
Locksmith Naperville IL
Naperville Locksmith
Locksmith Naperville
Locksmith Naperville
Locksmith Naperville IL
irvine locksmiths
mesquite tx locksmith
locksmith plano tx
miami beach locksmith
hialeah locksmiths
locksmith plano tx
mesquite tx locksmith
miami beach locksmith
miami beach locksmith
hialeah locksmiths
hialeah locksmith
hialeah locksmith
<a href="http://</a>

2:16 AM  
Blogger hope said...

nike air maxes have been issued and on the basis air max by better improvement It will be the most popular shoes of the world. discount nike air max are created a visual landmark and has greatly enhanced cushioning and stability. Nike Air max sale has been a big hit this spring with its neutral colorway a suitable match to a variety of fits.nike air max shoes have excellent materials and production.Cheap Nike Air max is made of multiple materials fused together for incredibly lightweight, breathable durability.Nike Air Griffey Max is very popular as Nike Air Max 2010 ,We sell nike air max 2011 and nike air zoom kobe, also sellnike air max tn, nike air max bwand cheap air max
.Buy cheap discount nike air max ltd and nike shoes us online with 40-70% off and Free shipping!We also sell for nike air max skyline ,nike air max shoes, nike collection,nike air max 1, nike air max 95, nike air max 180 and so on.High quality, incredible comfort and fashion are nike air max 24 7 and nike air max 87, It is worth to own nike air max 90 and nike air max 91.Welcome and happy purchasing online in nike air maxes.

2:53 AM  
Blogger abercrombiefitch said...

Be fast to browse the newest styles and lots of affordable outfits and Nike oxygen Max and women's merchandise is not an daily affair, for that reason that in the stress of modern day time girls ordinarily do not possess a complete great offer time and vitality to go buying by means of countless many style malls, and look at special fees will make you exhausted, so which you can acquire a satisfactory goods, call up for to devote lots of time, the show up of on collection buying significantly minimizing the inconvenience of this, now you not just can every one of the sudden go to to lots of goods Nike Air Max Shoes .

9:08 PM  
Blogger Candace said...

Whale Watching Costa Rica

http://www.dominicalcostaricatours.com/

2:20 AM  
Blogger Christian Louboutin sale said...

everybody talks about Christian Louboutin Platform Pumps Black Shoes coveted covered platform stilettos that are sold out everywhere.
Victoria Beckham, who is a loyal fans of cheap louboutin shoes, wore them to the Royal Wedding, in all their 6 inch glory, even though she was 6 months pregnant. Kim Kardashian favors the nude mary jane style, and so do Jennifer Hudson and Beyonce. Got your tax return? Time to snap these babies up now–we’ve rounded them up, below, or you can check Christian Louboutin shoes all out right here via Christian Louboutin sale online shop.

10:08 PM  
Blogger elizabeth bernot said...

Costa Rica Rafting

World Rafting Championships

9:51 PM  
Blogger Christian Louboutin sale said...

Create a real warming trend. Contoured silhouette make cheap moncler coats winter essential. For generations, world-class competitive skiers and mountaineers have turned to moncler uk for premium, performance-oriented apparel.Stay warm—and look cool—in this cozy quilted puffer,it's everything you could ever want out of cold-weather cheap moncler coats.

8:32 PM  
Blogger Christian Louboutin sale said...

Is it possible you don't have the ideal hair brush for your style? A Babyliss Hair Straightener give your cut that hairstyle you've been longing for.

8:33 PM  
Blogger Christian Louboutin sale said...

The low-pitched luxurious style of christian louboutin shoes on hot sale!The clean design lines and the signature red sole become a classic.

8:33 PM  
Blogger Christian Louboutin sale said...

Mirror, mirror on the wall, crystal is the fairest bauble of them all. This winter, let your feet marvel and sparkle with the likes of Lady Lynch Zeppa, Stellis, So Private, Calypso, Beaute Strass, Pigalle or made-to-measure crystallized high-tops(see Mika's latest cideo.) But be warned, crystal gazing can lead to a hypnotic state. There again, those darling Druids would beg to differ as would Queen Victoria who ordered up Crystal Palace and fervent fans of Naico Mine's 'Cave of the Gaints' in Chihuahua, Mexico. If visiting the latter, pack your Christian louboutin shoes and matching hairnet; the humidity is frizz bang outrageous.
DIscount moncler uk , cheap Babyliss Hair Straightener, CHI Hair Straightener.

1:06 AM  
Blogger Christian Louboutin sale said...

colorful quilted 'moncler uk ' short puffer down cheap moncler coats. Streamline your cold weather wardrobe with contemporary designs. Premium cheap moncler coats down fill provides lightweight warmth, enabling a figure-flattering silhouette. Is it possible you don't have the ideal hair brush for your style? A Babyliss Hair Straightener give your cut that hairstyle you've been longing for.
Here are the discount Christian louboutin shoes.

10:49 PM  
Anonymous Nike mercurial soccer cleats said...

Glad to see all the speakers, really wonderful content. Do not know if you like Nike mercurial soccer cleats or Nike soccer cleats and Nike Football Cleats,Nike Mercurial Vapor Superfly with New nike soccer shoes.

8:21 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Благодарю за информацию действительно увлекательно, однако меня также интересуют и новости голографии. Надо же развиваться в области голографии

5:06 AM  
Blogger Costa Rica Weddings said...

Costa
Rica Fishing Packages
, Costa
Rica Fishing Boats
, Costa Rica Fishing,
Costa Rica Sport
Fishing Packages
, Costa Rica
Fishing
, Costa Rica
Fishing Packages All Inclusive
, Fishing Trips Costa Rica,
Los Suenos Costa Rica Fishing,
Los Suenos Costa Rica Fishing Charters
, Costa Rica Fishing Vacation Packages,
Costa Rica Fishing Packages All
Inclusive
, Costa Rica Fishing
Trips
, Costa Rica Fishing Trips
All Inclusive
, Sport Fishing
Costa Rica
, Costa Rica Sport
Fishing Charters
, Sportfishing
In Costa Rica
, Jaco Costa Rica
Fishing Charters
, Jaco Costa
Rica Fishing Packages
, Jaco
Costa Rica Sport Fishing

12:18 PM  
Blogger Costa Rica Weddings said...

Costa Rica
Weddings
, Costa Rica
Wedding Packages
, Costa
Rica Weddings All Inclusive
,Wedding In Jaco Costa Rica,
Costa Rica Beach Weddings,
Los Suenos Wedding,
Jaco Costa Rica Wedding,
Jaco Wedding Planner,
Costa Rica Married,
Wedding Planning Costa Rica,
Costa Rica Wedding Locations,
Costa Rica Wedding Venues,
Costa Rica Wedding Packages All
Inclusive
, Costa Rica
Wedding Planner
, Getting
Married Costa Rica
, Costa
Rica Destination Weddings


Los Suenos Costa Rica,
Los Suenos Costa Rica Condos For Rent,
Los Suenos Costa Rica Vacation Rentals,
Los Suenos Condos For Rent,
Los Suenos Vacation Rentals,
Los Suenos Condominiums,
Los Suenos Condo Rental

5:02 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home